Bake My Day in Green Bay

4.6 /5
41 reviews

1203 E Mason St Green Bay WI 54301-3429

Restaurant Hours

Open Close

Monday undefined

Overview

Accessibility

  • undefined

Atmosphere

  • undefined

Base

  • undefined

Crowd

  • undefined

Dining Options

  • undefined

Highlights

  • Wheelchair accessible entrance

Offerings

  • undefined

Planning

  • undefined

Bake My Day, 1203 E Mason St Green Bay WI 54301-3429, Green Bay

Reviews

5

Best brownies cupcakes & cake in Green Bay! They also can put almost anything on a cake for you that you want.

5

Delicious free wedding cake tasting. Very friendly service!

3

The cake was alright. I wouldn't say it's nothing you couldn't get at your neighborhood Walmart or such. That being said, I'm not really sure what else it has to offer unless you're in the market for a specialty cake which will run you a bit. The place is very small so and I don't recall seating. I would say if you go you will probably just be in and out since you can't really get a bite to eat and consume it there.

5

I called Bake my Day to have cupcakes delivered. I told her I needed the cupcakes delivered early that day. The lady on the phone was extremely nice and had the cupcakes delivered in less than an hour. She also texted me a picture of the cupcakes and they were absolutely beautiful! Also the price was very reasonable. A huge thank you to bake my day for helping me make someone else's day(:

5

Great cupcakes. Great decorating. Daughter looking at getting wedding cake there.

3

I found this online while planning our vacation in the Green Bay area and thought it looked cute and cozy. When we stopped there no one was at the counter right away so we kind of stood there looking around. There is no room to sit down and there was not very much on display for a bakery, only cupcakes and muffins. An older woman came from the back and just stood there expectantly, not welcoming us or anything other than smiling. The cupcakes we decided on as a treat were pretty good, but I wouldn't go back to pay $2.50 each when they're standard size and don't have much frosting and aren't filled. A little bit of a disappointment but nothing that ruined our trip.

5

We had a very short list when it came to what we wanted for our wedding cake: 1) The best buttercream frosting in town. 2) Nothing to worry about. We got both from Bake My Day. They did absolutely beautiful work creating a wedding cake that perfectly fit with our wedding day. We rented their antique cake stand to pull the whole look together. We went old school, chocolate and vanilla, were delighted because the flavors were just so darn good. (Their other flavors are just as tasty, too. We just wanted something we could be sure everyone would love.) It was so good we decided to have the top of the cake the next day instead of waiting for our anniversary. We plan on coming back next year to get a new cake for that celebration!

5

We ordered a cake for a anniversary party. It was affordable and delicious. The staff was very helpful in choosing what we needed for the event. The only thing I was afraid of was that because desert was served with the meal we were having we were afraid that we were going to have a lot of cake left over but there were only two pieces left by the time the event had ended. Everyone said they enjoyed the cake especially the lemon poppy seed flavor. Thank you again for helping to make our party a success. I would absolutely recommend Bake my day to anyone needing a sweet treat for an event or just because.

5

I called Bake My Day well in advance of my girlfriends birthday for a special cake. Katie was so nice and able to help me out with all my planning. When I called a few weeks later to place the order Katie remembered me and made sure to get every last detail down to make the cake just what I wanted. Considering that I was able to call this cake in from NYC and for it to have been such a huge success with my gf and her coworkers, I would say this place is great! Katie and the staff at Bake My Day did an outstanding job on my girlfriend's birthday cake, couldn't have been more pleased. It came at a reasonable price too. Thank you Bake My Day for making my girlfriends surprise bday cake a huge success!

5

Highly recommend Bake My Day for your special occasion. Not only does everything they bake taste amazing but looks amazing too.

5

I used their services for our wedding cake a year ago, everyone loved it! The service was great and all the staff was friendly, helpful, and accommodating. Since our initial great experience we now use them for our kid's birthdays, and highly recommend them to friends and family.

5

Just got married today but I had to write a review for Bake My Day before bed! After seeing how professional their website was, I decided to have a bridesmaid try their cakes. They were really nice people and the cupcakes got rave reviews (both on taste and visual appeal - they look exactly like they do in the pictures!) When I finally got to town I got to see their storefront, which is this cute little bakery like you'd see in Chicago. They set up our cupcake display on time and even made my custom cake topper look awesome on top of the anniversary cake (which was free with the cupcakes!) The guests loved the cupcakes and I'm so glad everything went exactly as planned. Thank you BMD!

5

Love the cakes & cup cakes. They did an amazing job on my wedding cake! Amazing customer sercive!

5

Their cupcakes are incredible!

5

We had them do our wedding cake- a beautiful three tiered (chocolate with raspberry filling, white with raspberry filling, and lemon poppyseed with lemon filling). This was seriously the best cake I have ever had in my entire life. It was even better than the samples we were given when picking out our flavors. We got so many compliments from all of our guests on it too. One word- phenomenal.

5

Great bakery. The cakes are always done to the highest standards. Stop by to get some cupcakes to share with friends.

1

Order unfrosted cutout cookies. They were dried out and pretty chewy for a sugar cookie. Tasted like cheap pl frozen cookies. Old

5

Lovely work! Priced right!

5

I just ordred a cake for my son that lives in that area, who is originally from California. Katie was a doll, thank you for making it easy. I'm sure my son Vincent will enjoy it...... :)

5

Thank you Joan and Katie for my granddaughters first cake!!...Linda Fifield!!

5

They made a amazing wedding cake for us. The staff is very friendly and patient. The cake for our wedding looked amazing and tasted fantastic. We recieved so many compliments on the look and taste of our cake. They installed the cake ornament for our cake and it looked amazing. We ordered cupcakes with our cake and they were amazing. Looked beautiful and tasted great. The delivery was timed perfectly and the final set up was beautiful. I highly recommend Bake My Day.

5

Wonderful local bakery with great brownies

4

Not much stock but sweet lady and amazing cupcakes!

5

Love Bake My Day! You will never be let down with their service or bakery!

5

Absolutely amazing service. So many options of cake flavors. Delicious! Always get compliments when I bring Bake My Day cakes or cupcakes in. Would highly recommend.

5

Walked in to purchase cupcakes and was immediately greeted. Then I was offered to try the delicious flavors of cake they make. Orange and Armaretto was so good! I ended up ordering a birthday cake for my husband's birthday which is in a couple weeks. I can't wait! Margarita cupcake was very tasty!

5

Very rich your cakes I recommend it

5

This is the only bakery we will ever go to! We've ordered dozens of cakes from here for various occasions and they were beautiful and delicious every single time. I especially like that the staff is able to meet special requests for decorating! When my stepdaughter turned 16, they decorated her cake to look like a license and even included her picture on the cake.

5

Amazing thank you guy's so much for the beautiful baby girl shower cake😇

5

We order all our special occasion cakes from Bake My Day. They have the best cake flavors and frosting. My future husband isn't a fan of frosting, but he loves the cake from here. Super sweet ladies to order from too! Can't wait to see our wedding cake in May!

5

Another awesome experience with a cake order!!!!

3

They didn't have any time to talk to me about a cake I want it so I left I had a sample though and it was delicious

5

Awesome cupcakes

5

I ordered my wedding cake from Bake My Day and I’m so glad I did. I had a wonderful customer service experience. Three tiers (amaretto, marble, and strawberry flavor).

5

Good service and great employees

5

We stopped by the morning after Thanksgiving and selected 4 cupcakes and a muffin. My husband loved the Mint Chocolate, it was his favorite & I personally loved the Strawberry Rhubarb muffin the most, delish!

3

Overall experience was good, and cupcake was delicious. However, was not impressed by the cake decorated for my son's birthday at cost of $35 prepaid, before seeing the cake. Hard to even identify the sloppy picture. Hoping it tastes as good as the cupcake tried.

5

Bake my day did an amazing job on our wedding cake and cupcakes!!! Our wedding was July 21st 2018 and I went in that morning to pick up our cake and cupcakes! Let me tell you, They did such an amazing job on the cupcakes, followed all our colors and just absolutely great and they tasted amazing too! Now our cake! We got a groomsman cake for just us to cut and so on... I was expecting the cake to be smaller and so on. The cake was half of the Death Star. They did AMAZING! The details were great and the size was bigger than expected. Plus the price was astounding!I will forever and always recommend bake my day to anyone. Even for birthday cakes I would recommend! Thank you guys!

5

Love this place, I would highly recommend, fair prices and a friendly staff when I have gone in. Their cupcakes are amazing.

5

My favorite cake shop in town I always order from bake my day because I know I'm never disappointed ever always tastes good even 5-7days after! I always order you guys for my birthday every yr I always request BAKE MY DAY! No other cake stands up to you guys!

5

Delicious cupcakes